Is Frontier or Spectrum a better fit for you?
- Frontier Fiber plans cost $39.99-$149.99/mo.* and typically increase in year two.
- Spectrum internet plans cost $49.99- $109.99/mo.* and increase by $25/mo. in year two.
- Frontier Fiber plans have download/upload speeds of 500/500, 940/880 and 2000/2000 Mbps.
- Spectrum plans have download/upload speeds of 200/10, 400/20 and 1000/35 Mbps.
- Spectrum has higher customer satisfaction scores than Frontier.
*Pricing per month plus taxes. Additional fees and terms may apply. Pricing varies by location and availability. All prices subject to change at any time. May or may not be available based on service address. As of 03/07/22.
Our pick: If you can get Frontier’s fiber optic internet service at your address, that’s your best option. But if you’re picking between Frontier’s DSL internet and Spectrum, we’d go with Spectrum.
|Category||Frontier DSL||Frontier Fiber||Spectrum|
How we scored internet providers
We evaluate broadband providers in four categories: affordability, performance, value and customer satisfaction. Each category contains multiple sub-factors, all of which are weighted differently to impact the provider’s overall score.
For each sub-factor, we score all providers on a continuous scale of 1 to 5, relative to the industry as a whole. Because the average download speed in America is currently 180 Mbps, for example, we assigned all plans with download speeds between 100 and 299 Mbps a score between 3 and 4. Xfinity’s 200 Mbps plan received a 3.50 score for download speed, while Spectrum’s 400 Mbps plan got a 4.16.
We only considered standardized data points in our scoring system. More abstract data like consistency of service and brand reputation is still part of our analysis, but we opted to let our writers address them in the context of each review.Learn more about our methodology
Frontier vs. Spectrum internet
The choice between Frontier and Spectrum internet really comes down to which connection type is available at your address. Frontier Fiber will get you the fastest speeds and best value, while Spectrum’s cable internet is a little slower and more expensive. Still, Spectrum is much faster than Frontier DSL service, which should be viewed as a last resort for most people.
Frontier Fiber internet plans
|Feature||500/500||Gig Service||Fiber 2 Gig|
|Download speed||500 Mbps||940 Mbps||2,000 Mbps|
|Upload speed||500 Mbps||880 Mbps||2,000 Mbps|
Frontier DSL plans
Frontier’s DSL internet plans use your phone line to deliver an internet connection. You’ll automatically get the fastest speeds available at your address. Speeds vary depending on location.
Spectrum internet plans
Spectrum offers up to three internet plans — Spectrum Internet, Internet Ultra and Internet Gig — in most areas with available speeds ranging from 60 to 1000 Mbps. You’ll find details on Spectrum internet plans below.
|Spectrum plan||Download speed*||Upload speed*||Starting price||Price after 12 mos.|
|Internet||300 Mbps||10 Mbps||$49.99/mo.||$74.99/mo.|
|Internet Ultra||500 Mbps||20 Mbps||$69.99/mo.||$94.99/mo.|
|Internet Gig||1,000 Mbps||35 Mbps||$89.99/mo.||$114.99/mo.|
*Wireless speeds may vary.
Which internet plan should you choose?
Frontier’s mid-level fiber optic plan offers the best combination of speed and affordability. Right now, Frontier is offering it for just $54.99/mo. The same price with Spectrum gets you less than half the speed. With 500 Mbps download and upload speeds, all but the largest, most connected households will have plenty of bandwidth for streaming, gaming and video calls.
Frontier’s Fiber 2 Gig is one of the fastest internet plans in the country. You’ll get 2000 Mbps download and upload speed. Most people don’t need all that bandwidth, but if you do a lot of gaming or have a well-connected smart home, it might be worth the upgrade.
Which provider offers the cheapest internet plans?
In areas where Spectrum and Frontier are both available, Frontier will likely present the lowest-priced internet options. Depending on the plan you choose, however, Spectrum plans may come with more speed for the price, making it a better value.
Spectrum’s cheapest plan offers a bit more speed than Frontier, but you’ll also get an added equipment fee of $5/mo. Frontier internet plan pricing already includes the cost of equipment rental.
Which provider offers the fastest internet plans?
Depending where you live, Frontier may offer fiber internet speeds up to 2000 Mbps, but this availability is limited.
Spectrum’s gig internet offers speeds up to 1000 Mbps and are available in the majority of Spectrum service areas. Spectrum upload speeds range from 10 to 35 Mbps, depending on your plan. Gigabit plans with download speeds up to 1000 Mbps have upload speeds up to 35 Mbps, plans from 300 to 400 Mbps carry upload speeds up to 20 Mbps and lower tier plans have upload speeds up to 10 Mbps.
Frontier Fiber internet plans will include upload speeds that are equivalent to their download speeds.
Additional things to consider
The price you see when you’re shopping for internet is rarely the same as what shows up on your first bill. In addition to taxes, most providers charge extra fees for equipment rental, installation and data overages. Here’s how Frontier and Spectrum compare when it comes to those extra considerations.
Both providers are pretty generous in this category. While you can typically expect to pay between $10 and $15/mo. to rent a modem and router from your internet provider, Spectrum only charges $5/mo. and Frontier doesn’t charge anything.
Frontier charges a flat $85 fee for all installations, while Spectrum is just $10.
You won’t have to worry about data caps on any of Spectrum’s or Frontier’s plans. All of them come with unlimited data.
Neither Spectrum or Frontier require you to commit to a contract when you subscribe, so you won’t have to worry about early termination fees if you move or switch providers.
What shoppers should consider in different regions
Both providers’ pricing and package options vary across the U.S., especially Frontier’s. Frontier offers different internet speeds in separate regions. Frontier also tends to offer higher internet speeds with bundles than with standalone internet plans.
Spectrum and Frontier both have select availability with TV services, too. In different areas, each provider may only offer TV service as part of a bundle. Because internet speed pricing changes so much and standalone options aren’t comparable in certain regions, potential “bundle savings” can differ across the U.S.
Frontier vs. Spectrum bundles
Spectrum and Frontier offer comparable TV channel packages and premium channel promotions. Because Spectrum is a cable provider, it offers cable TV to bundle with its internet plans. Spectrum bundles cost between $90 and $140/mo. in most areas, and go up by $32/mo. in the second year.
Frontier, on the other hand, doesn’t offer TV plans itself, so you’ll have to add a TV service like DISH or DIRECTV STREAM separately. Unfortunately, these aren’t discounted at all, so there’s no real advantage to bundling with Frontier.
Frontier Fiber 500 + DIRECTV STREAM ENTERTAINMENT
- Starting at $108.98/mo.*
- Download speeds up to 500 Mbps
- Unlimited data
- 65+ channels
- No contract
Spectrum Double Play Select
- Starting at $89.98/mo.*
- Download speeds up to 200 Mbps*
- Unlimited data
- 125+ channels
- No contract
- Price increases to $121.98/mo. in second year
*Wireless speeds may vary. Pricing per month plus taxes for length of contract. Additional fees and terms may apply. Pricing varies by location and availability. All prices subject to change at any time. May or may not be available based on service address. As of 03/07/22.
Frontier vs. Spectrum customer satisfaction
Generally, customers are happier with Spectrum than Frontier. We looked at three sources when comparing customer satisfaction between providers: The American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), Consumer Reports and J.D. Power. In each one, Frontier received a significantly lower score. Frontier has been improving steadily over the past few years, but so has Spectrum, so there’s still a significant gap.
Because the majority of Frontier’s service area is limited to DSL connections, complaints about service typically center around slow speeds. If you can get Frontier Fiber at your address, this shouldn’t be an issue. Still, that doesn’t explain its “poor” score for technical support from Consumer Reports readers, or the thousands of complaints with the Better Business Bureau about Frontier’s customer service and sales issues.
Frontier filed for bankruptcy in April 2020, and went public again in May 2021. With new leadership and a focus on building out its fiber optic network, it’s possible that Frontier’s service will look a lot different going forward. But so far, that hasn’t been reflected in its customer satisfaction scores.
If you live in an area with Frontier Fiber service, we think that’s the best option for most people. It offers the fastest speeds, and its price is actually a bit cheaper than Spectrum. But if you can only get Frontier DSL, Spectrum’s cable internet will be far more reliable. It’s also worth noting that customers are overwhelmingly more satisfied with their service from Spectrum, but it’s safe to assume that many of the bad experiences with Frontier are with its DSL service.
We value your feedback
Was this page helpful?
We value your feedback
We’re glad! Tell us what helped most on this page.
We value your feedback
Was this page helpful?
Thanks for your feedback!
Your insight helps, and we’ll do our best to improve your experience.
Written by:Joe Supan
Senior Writer, Broadband Content
Joe Supan is the senior writer for Allconnect and MyMove. He has helped build the proprietary metrics used on Allconnect’s review pages, utilizing thousands of data points to help readers navigate these comple… Read more
Edited by:Robin Layton
Editor, Broadband Content
- FeaturedBest modems & routers for Frontier Allconnect — 5 min read
- FeaturedThe best Spectrum-compatible modems and routers for 2022 Lisa Iscrupe — 4 min read
- FeaturedFiber vs. cable: What’s the best option for you? Ari Howard — 2 min read
Thursday, August 4, 20222022 report: Internet users are gobbling data by the half-terabyte
Robin Layton — 4 min read
Thursday, July 21, 2022Guide to insomnia and technology
Lara Vukelich — 6 min read
Wednesday, July 20, 2022If the internet went down for a day, what’s the worst that could happen?
Robin Layton — 8 min read
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for internet news and promos
By subscribing, you agree to receive Allconnect newsletter and promotional emails. Your privacy is important to us.
Thanks for subscribing!
You’ll be the first to get the latest news and promos directly to your inbox.