As the U.S. looks to find ways to connect all Americans to affordable high-speed internet, one option that has become increasingly considered is government-run internet service, known as municipal internet. This means instead of a private internet company like national providers Xfinity and Spectrum or more regional providers like Rise Broadband, the local government of a town or city would offer internet service to its residents.
This is a fairly new option since the majority of states, up until just a few years ago, had strict bans on municipal broadband. As of 2021, however, this number has been lowered to 17 states. The most recent state to permit municipal broadband in its state was in Arkansas in February 2021.
Now that municipal broadband has become a more prevalent option throughout the country, many towns, including Springfield MA, are looking into taking the leap.
But how does the public feel about municipal broadband as an alternative to private internet service providers (ISPs)?
Morning Consult, a private data intelligence company, released a report on how Americans feel about municipal broadband compared to private ISPs. The federal government is pushing for more cities to look into municipal broadband, so Morning Consult surveyed over 2,000 Americans in April 2021 to determine if this is an option Americans will support.
Here are the main takeaways from the report.
Trust in municipal broadband
The majority of Americans reported trust in local municipal broadband, but they still had more trust in private ISPs overall.
According to the report, 54% of adults reported “a lot” or “some trust” in municipal broadband and 75% of adults reported “a lot” or “some trust” in private internet providers. This means that while the majority of adults trust both government and private internet providers, more adults trust private providers.
Trust in municipal broadband: 54%
Trust in private ISPs: 75%
Urban residents had more trust in government-run broadband than rural residents, but urban and rural residents had equal levels of trust for private internet providers.
When broken down by community, the results revealed that urban residents are more likely to trust local municipal providers than rural residents. In fact, less than half of rural residents (49%) reported trust in a local government being able to provide the best at home-internet service.
In comparison, 63% of urban residents reported trust in municipal broadband. Rural and urban residents, however, reported similar rates of trust for private ISPs (72% vs. 74%).
This is a somewhat surprising finding since rural residents are disproportionately affected by the digital divide (lack of internet access). In other words, despite having the worst experience with private internet providers, rural residents are still not optimistic that a government-run internet option would be a better solution.
Even more surprising, rural residents are just as likely as urban residents to report trust for private ISPs.
Support for municipal broadband
Majority of adults believe local governments should be able to become internet providers
One of the greatest shifts in thinking surrounding broadband access has been support for municipal broadband expansion in the past few years. According to Morning Consult, 53% of adults currently believe local governments should be allowed to build their own networks. In fact, only 14% of adults disapprove of government-run broadband.
Democrats and urban residents are more supportive of municipal broadband than Republicans and rural residents
Disapproval is highest when broken down by political party lines, where 52% of Republicans either out-right disapprove of government-run broadband (19%) or are unsure about it (33%). In contrast, 59% of Democrats fully support municipal broadband.
The results are similar to Republicans and Democrats when comparing rural and urban residents. For instance, 53% of rural residents either out-right disapprove of municipal broadband (16%) or are unsure about municipal broadband (37%). The majority of urban residents (57%), however, fully approve of municipal broadband.
What are the reservations?
The Morning Consult did not survey Americans on why they were more comfortable with private internet providers over municipal providers overall. However, there are some theories.
The first is that municipal broadband is somewhat of a new concept and it will take time for people to warm-up to the idea. It is possible that people want to stick with what is familiar to them. This may change as more small cities begin reporting their successes with municipal broadband investments.
For instance, Chattanooga, TN recently reported that investing in municipal broadband attracted movers to their city because they were able to provide affordable, Gig-speed internet to every single one of its residents. As a result, Chattanooga has raised over $2.69 billion from its investment in municipal internet over the past decade.
However, not all cities have been as successful with its broadband investments. The local government in Provo, Utah, for instance, had to sell its broadband infrastructure to Google once they realized they could not continue to finance the project. The fear for many, therefore, is that municipal broadband will just become a money pit for the city since deployment and upkeep is expensive.
For that reason, many would prefer to leave it to the experts and just pay a little extra for internet service or receive slightly slower internet speeds. This is certainly the safer option, especially in cities where major internet providers already exist.
However, for those who cannot afford internet service or who live in an area without any high-speed internet options, this is not a viable solution. Without more competition for private internet companies and greater investments in high quality broadband infrastructure, such as fiber optic, internet access will continue to be a leading issue in the U.S. People who currently lack good broadband options will likely continue to struggle to find services that offer the kinds of speeds they need.
Allconnect: Let us compare providers for you
Why should you choose Allconnect? We’re the #1 broadband marketplace in the U.S, meaning you can trust us to search, compare and order internet and TV service for your home.Get started
Written by:Ari Howard
Associate Writer, Broadband & Wireless Content
Ari is an Associate Writer for the Allconnect team. She primarily writes about broadband news and studies, particularly relating to internet access, digital safety, broadband-related technology and the digital d… Read more
Edited by:Robin Layton
Editor, Broadband Content
- FeaturedDoes this Tennessee city have the blueprint to solve the digital divide? Ari Howard — 8 min read
- FeaturedSpringfield may become the first big city in New England to invest in municipal internet. Will others follow? Ari Howard — 3 min read
- FeaturedNeed a reason to move? Check out the cheap high-speed internet in these small cities! Samantha Cossick — 6 min read