Once you’ve selected your internet service provider and the plan that works best for you, it’s easy to think that your shopping is over. However, your last decision — your choice of whether to rent or buy a router and modem and if you do buy, which router or modem that is — can be your most important of all. A simple long-term cost and quality comparison are all you need to make the right choice for you.
Do you need a modem and a router?
You may be wondering: “Do I even need a modem and router?” and the answer is yes if you’re looking to wirelessly connect devices in your home to the internet.
Your modem connects your local home network to the internet and a Wi-Fi router allows you to connect multiple devices wirelessly to your internet connection. Internet service providers often offer a single 2-in-1 device with an integrated modem and router as an option for monthly rental. However, if you have the option to purchase your own equipment, you may be able to save money in the long run by doing so.
Pros and cons of renting a modem and router
Provider customer support
Guaranteed software updates
Easy to return the equipment
Guaranteed provider and speed compatibility
Repair services included with service
Monthly rental payment with service
Payments only go toward usage
Pros and cons of buying a modem and router
Reduce your annual internet bill by owning your own equipment
You pick your equipment instead of the provider
Repair and equipment upgrades are your responsibility after a warranty expire
Customer support may be limited after the warranty expires or the age of device increases
Will I save more money buying or renting a modem and router?
Buying your own modem and router is a great option for you if:
- Plan on keeping your internet access for more than a year
- Have the option to use your own equipment
- Don’t have roommates that you’ll need to split the cost with
- Have the patience to do some preliminary research
- Plan to customize your equipment in the future
Most providers charge $5-15/mo. to rent a 2-in-1 modem and router device, commonly known as a “gateway.” Some providers, like CenturyLink and Verizon Fios, give you the option to purchase this equipment upfront and potentially save money without having to go through a third-party vendor. Purchasing provider equipment may be the best way to go if you plan on signing a contract with the provider and the cost of the equipment is less than the total cost of the equipment rental.
Cost: Rental vs. purchase of a modem/router
In most cases, the upfront cost of a modem and router pays for itself within a year. Equipment fees for internet providers are usually around $10/mo. and you can buy combination modem/routers for under $100.
The table below shows equipment fees from the top providers in the country, along with the retail prices for their compatible modems and routers. Most ISPs provide a list of compatible devices in case you’re interested in using your own device for service. If you can find equipment that’s cheaper but good quality, you may save even more money by going this route.
*Modem/router prices taken from manufacturer’s websites, buyyourownmodem.com and Amazon (updated 04/21/21)
In the examples above, you could save as much as $118 in the first year by buying instead of renting through Xfinity. Your investment would essentially pay for itself after month four.
Check out the articles below for complete lists of modems and routers that work with each provider:
- Mediacom-compatible modems
- Windstream-compatible modems and routers
- Spectrum-compatible routers
- CenturyLink-compatible modems and routers
- Verizon-compatible routers
What kind of modem and router do I need?
The modem and router you need will depend on what kind of internet plan you’re signed up for. For customers with at least 250 Mbps, an ISP-compatible gateway device like the NETGEAR Nighthawk AC1900 is a good investment. This device will cost you more than the yearly rental fee for a device from each provider, but you would own your own device for future use with other ISPs. Check out some more gateway devices that work with multiple providers and have earned high reviews from internet users just like you.
- ARRIS SURFboard AC1900 – Compatible with Cox, Spectrum, Suddenlink and Xfinity
- MOTOROLA MD1600 – Compatible with CenturyLink, Frontier and Windstream
- NETGEAR N300 – Compatible with Cox, Spectrum, Suddenlink and Xfinity
It’s also worth noting that many ISP-compatible gateway devices are of higher quality and work better than ISP-provided devices. Oftentimes, ISPs just give you the bare minimum in equipment to maximize their return on rental fees.
If your ISP doesn’t offer the option to use your own modem and router, then your only option would be to select a different provider or to use the mandatory equipment and hope the damage isn’t too bad on your monthly bill. Some providers, like AT&T, even offer their equipment rental at no additional cost when you sign up for their top plans.
Tips for buying a router and modem
The best way to maximize your investment in internet equipment is to know what kind of device you need to support your internet activities and your household. Also, decide whether or not you’ll want to purchase a gateway device as we used in the examples above or separate modem and Wi-Fi router devices.
Separate devices are great if you can see yourself upgrading your home network or broadband speed. In either case, you’d simply need to replace your router or modem. To make this change to a gateway router/modem device, you’d have to upgrade and replace the entire device.
Next, consider the download speeds and data plan, if applicable, of your internet plan and make sure to choose a device that’s capable of delivering those speeds. If all else fails, check out the list of compatible devices commonly offered by ISPs with the option to use your own equipment. Many well-known providers like Cox, Spectrum and Xfinity provide extensive lists of alternatives by internet speed tier so you can pick a model based on your plan.
We recommend at least referencing these lists before you buy a device. Purchasing equipment that is incompatible with your provider, internet speeds and level of activity could make your investment a flop, especially if you can’t even enjoy your internet service.
Written by:Taylor Gadsden
Writer, Broadband Content
Taylor is a veteran member of the Allconnect content team and has spearheaded a number of projects, including a data piece on the top fiber cities in the U.S. and a troubleshooting guide on how to connect your p… Read more
Edited by:Robin Layton
Editor, Broadband Content
- FeaturedThe five best wireless routers of 2022 Camryn Smith — 7 min read
- FeaturedThe best modems & routers for gaming AJ Dellinger — 6 min read
- FeaturedWhat’s the difference between a modem and a router? Taylor Gadsden — 5 min read
Tuesday, September 27, 2022Guide to 5G spectrum bands
Robin Layton — 3 min read
Tuesday, September 27, 2022$502M awarded for rural high-speed internet connections
Robin Layton — 2 min read
Thursday, September 22, 2022The U.S. has the 6th fastest internet speed in the world, but many are still left behind
Joe Supan — 4 min read