Which streaming service has the best original shows and movies? We scraped the data to find out

Joe Supan

Apr 24, 2020 — 6 min read

We tallied user ratings, critical reviews and awards successes on more than 2,000 shows and movies to determine where to find the best original programming.

At Allconnect, we work to present quality information with editorial integrity. While this post may contain offers from our partners, our opinions are our own. Here’s how we make money.

When Netflix first launched its streaming plan in 2007, it was little more than a novelty.

The company was still firmly in the shipping-DVDs-to-subscribers business, touting its new “streaming” option as a cutting-edge perk to a Netflix membership.

It would be another six years until Netflix produced its first original series, House of Cards. The show would go on to receive 56 Emmy nominations over six seasons, but it changed the landscape even more dramatically than that number illustrates.

In 2020, Netflix is still shipping DVDs and licensing content, but original shows and movies are clearly the future of streaming. Netflix is expected to spend $17 billion on content this year, with 85% going to originals.

Even though licensed shows are by far the most popular titles on the service — according to Nielsen data, they made up 72% of viewing minutes in 2018 — Netflix is losing them at a dramatic rate.

As companies like Disney, NBC, and WarnerMedia pull streaming comfort food like Friends and The Office for their own streaming services, Netflix will be forced to rely on its own original content to keep subscribers.

(Netflix’s primary competitors, Amazon Prime Video and Hulu are more insulated from this trend. Prime Video is one of many perks of an Amazon Prime membership, while Hulu is controlled by Disney.)

So that left us wondering: Which streaming service actually has the best original content?

How we evaluated original shows and movies on each streaming service

We focused our search on the biggest names in streaming, both old and new: Netflix, Prime Video, Hulu, HBO Max, SHOWTIME, STARZ, Disney+, Apple TV+, CBS All Access and Quibi.

From there, we evaluated each streaming service on three criteria, giving equal weight to each one.

Audience ratings

First, we looked at how general audiences received each streaming service’s original shows and movies. To do this, we used both IMDb’s user ratings and Rotten Tomatoes’ audience score, which shows the percentage of all users who rated a title 3.5 or higher out of five. We collected both ratings for every piece of original content, with one caveat: We set a baseline requirement of 100 ratings to be included in our scores.

Critical reception

To gauge how critics viewed each service’s original content, we utilized Rotten Tomatoes’ Tomatometer® score. The metric scores TV seasons and movies once at least five professional critics have weighed in. If an original title had enough critic reviews for a score, we included it.

Awards recognition

Finally, we considered how many Emmy, Oscar and Golden Globe nominations and wins each service has garnered since 2013, the first year a streaming service was nominated for a major award. (Netflix received four Emmy nominations for House of Cards that year and one for Arrested Development.)

However, we didn’t include every award in our count. Each event gets incredibly specific with their awards, and we didn’t want to give the same weight to “Outstanding Production Design For A Narrative Period Or Fantasy Program (One Hour Or More)” as “Outstanding Drama Series.”

Here is the full list of awards that we included in our count.

Why we didn’t factor volume into our score

Anyone who’s ever scrolled through Netflix for an hour without picking something to watch knows that more isn’t necessarily better. But it does matter to some degree.

For example, Netflix has nearly 1,200 original titles in its library, while Hulu has fewer than 80. The more original shows and movies a service has, the more likely it is you’ll find something you want to watch.

That said, our goal was to determine how good each service’s original content is, not how much it has. Netflix clearly has a throw-everything-at-the-wall-and-see-what-sticks approach, and we didn’t want to reward it for sheer volume alone.

What about shows that moved over to streaming services?

For shows like Arrested Development or Veronica Mars that started their initial run on cable or network TV and moved over to a streaming service later, we only used critic and user ratings from the seasons in which they were produced by the streaming service.

Here’s how each streaming service’s original shows and movies compare

HBO Max came out on top in our analysis by a significant margin, especially when it came to the response from critics. While it has about half as many original titles in its library as Netflix, they are of a markedly higher quality.

It wasn’t entirely unexpected — HBO finds a way to dominate the TV conversation every year with shows like Game of Thrones and Big Little Lies — but its lead on the other streaming services was still stark.

HBO Max: Best original shows and movies

HBO Max has the second-highest audience ratings from IMDb, it’s the best-reviewed from critics and it’s also won the most awards, by far. It excelled in every metric we used.

HBO Max’s 521 original TV shows and movies earned an average rating of 7.3 from IMDb’s users (behind only STARZ), and it was 2% higher than second-place Disney+ on its average Tomatometer® scores.

That success has translated to the major awards, too. Since 2013, HBO has gotten more Emmy nominations and wins than any streaming service, and it’s not particularly close.

While Netflix, Hulu and Prime Video have one or two awards hits each year, HBO dominates the Emmys consistently with shows like Barry, VeepLast Week Tonight and Game of Thrones. If you want to keep up with the most praised shows on TV, HBO Max is your best bet by far.

Netflix: Most Oscars

Netflix ranked in the middle of the pack in all of our categories, but it does stand out in one particular area: highly lauded original films.

Much of that is volume — Netflix actually had a lower average score than HBO Max, Prime Video, Hulu and Disney+ from audiences and critics alike on its original movies — but it’s the only streaming service to show up in a significant way at the Oscars. In 2020, for example, Netflix received 24 nominations in the major categories, and even took home two statues.

This looks to be Netflix’s game plan going forward. It’s the only streaming service investing significant money in original movies — 257 of HBO Max’s 343 movies are documentaries — and the only one attracting major names like Martin Scorsese, Will Smith and Sandra Bullock to its movies.

If anything, these metrics might underrate the quality of Netflix’s film library — because they don’t typically show them in theaters, most of Netflix’s original movies don’t qualify for Oscars.

Disney+: Best newcomer

Of the three streaming services that have launched over the past year, Disney+ has clearly gotten off to the strongest start. Its 20 original shows have an average Rotten Tomatoes critic score of 87% — higher even than HBO Max’s 83%.

Everyone knows about the hit Star Wars spinoff The Mandalorian, but Disney+ has also gotten a positive response from shows like The Imagineering Story and films like Togo. Of course, these services have produced only a fraction of the original content that services like Netflix and Prime Video have, but the early returns look promising for Disney+.

The bottom line

Each streaming service’s original content has its own strengths and weaknesses, but HBO Max is the clear winner when it comes to both shows and movies. It ranks highest in Emmys collected, critical response and a close second in audience scores. While Netflix has closed the gap in recent years, it still doesn’t produce as many reliable hits as HBO.

The only service that graded out relatively poorly in our analysis was Hulu, and that’s not altogether surprising. Aside from The Handmaid’s Tale, it hasn’t made a major investment in original content. Instead, they’ve focused on licensed shows from network TV.

As NBC’s Peacock and HBO MAX debut over the next few months, we’ll continue to update our scorecard. Until then check out our Resource CenterFacebook and Twitter for all the latest streaming news.

Allconnect Watermark

Choose streaming services that match your watching habits when you compare on Allconnect.

Shop streaming services
Joe Supan

Written by:

Joe Supan

Senior Writer, Broadband Content

Joe oversees all things broadband for Allconnect. His work has been referenced by Yahoo!, Lifehacker and more. He has utilized thousands of data points to build a library of metrics to help users navigate these … Read more

Trey Paul

Edited by:

Trey Paul

Editor, Head of Content

Read bio